Search Computing Unplugged's 18,096 article archive 
Home
EasyPrint
News details Click here for the RSS feed's XML code. This is not a browser URL.
Articles-only Click here for the RSS feed's XML code. This is not a browser URL.
Twitter Feed Click here for the Twitter feed.
PDA phone wars: the Treo 700w vs. the Treo 650 vs. the PPC-6700 (continued)

The phone companies
Unfortunately, when you're talking about PDA phones, you're stuck with the major carriers. I reviewed the Treo 700w running on the Verizon network, the PPC-6700 running on the Sprint network, and I have my own Treo 650, also running on Sprint.

If you're excited about using the Bluetooth capabilities of the devices, along with the blazing fast EvDO network as a high-speed interface for your laptop, you're going to be disappointed. Reader Joe Ellett sent us a note that describes the problem quite clearly:

It's worth noting that the XV6700 is Verizon's version of the HTC Wizard. The Wizard is sold by all major wireless companies, so if you're not a Verizon customer you can still get this extremely functional and well-designed converged device. In the US, T-Mobile sells the MDA, Cingular sells the 8125, and Sprint sells the PPC-6700. Outside the US, the device is available from T-Mobile, Qtek, i-mate, Orange and others.
The models are virtually identical in features, but differ in some details. For instance, the T-Mobile MDA is much sleeker than the XV6700, with a curved body that fits the hand better and no external antenna, but the MDA lacks a cradle. As of early 2006, each model supports its vendor's highest-speed data network.
It's also worthwhile to note that the T-Mobile and Cingular GSM models have unimpaired Bluetooth functionality, while Verizon and Sprint continue to cripple their Bluetooth stacks to force users to pay for extra plan features or messaging charges. The GSM models incorporate quad-band phones, so once they're unlocked they're eminently suitable for international roaming.
In addition to its other talents, the Wizard is a competent MP3 player. The addition of a 1GB miniSD card (available on-line for about $50) gives the Wizard the capacity of the smallest iPod nano, and 2GB MiniSD cards are expected to hit the market within a matter of weeks. Windows Mobile 5.0 doesn't support the Bluetooth ADSP profile yet, but the WM5 Service Pack 1 due out later this year will add ADSP, giving WM5 devices the capability to support Bluetooth wireless stereo headphones.
Try an HTC Wizard from any vendor and you'll find that these days The Force is definitely with the Dark Side.

Frankly, we find this continual crippling of the Bluetooth interface to prevent the phone from acting as a high-speed laptop modem idiotic. As much as we'd like to recommend these phones highly, the crippling of the Bluetooth stack has caused us to drop a complete point off our rating for both the Treo 700w and the PPC-6700.

Conclusions
This has been a tough review to write, because it's not just a product shootout between three devices. While examining the Treo 700w, we've been trying to crystal ball the future of Palm as a company simply by what's included in this one device.

There's no real way we can see into the future. We've counted Palm down before and they've come back with some excellent products. But we're concerned.


« Previous  ·  1  ·  2  ·  3  ·  4  ·  5  ·  Next »
Other articles you might like
Home > Phones and PDAs > Palm and Treo > Devices (65 articles)
   Should die-hard Palm users consider a Pre?
   Palm performs Foleo mercy killing
   Hands on with the (relatively) inexpensive Treo 680
Home > Phones and PDAs > Windows Mobile > Devices (14 articles)
   Are you a gadgethound or techno geek? The HTC Advantage might be for you.
   Hands-on with the HTC Touch -- is it an iPhone killer?
   The Cingular 8525 is a top-shelf Pocket PC phone
Home > Reviews > Devices (84 articles)
   Oh, sweet SATAsfaction
   Why we can't recommend the Acer Aspire One
   We review Revell Vexplorer Robotics System
Get Weekly Email Updates
Subscribe to our regular weekly email newsletter. It's packed with tips, reviews, deep analysis, and the latest news.
 
Recent Computing Unplugged Articles
Wecome to the ZATZ Studio
HTC's HD7, the HD2 update
Is Windows Phone 7 for power users?
Open question: what would you like to see us cover?
Citizen journalism: is it sustainable?
Nik Software's HDR Efex Pro reveals photographic details previously hidden to the naked eye
Status report: migrating ZENPRESS to a new platform
Computing Unplugged News
Tiny Raspberry Pi PC Arrives in Late February
Something fishy about Google Chrome's Safe Browsing API
Nokia will lay off 4,000
First-Generation Ultrabook Prices May Drop
Mac OS X ARM port by Apple
"Deleted" Facebook photos are still online
Google to strip Chrome of SSL revocation checking
>> Read all the news
More from the ZATZ journals
David Gewirtz Online: CNN commentary and analysis
DominoPower: Lotusphere 2012: The Notes client and the new Notes browser plugin
-- Advertisement --

ONLINE GROUP CALENDAR - FOR UP TO 100 OF YOUR CLOSEST FRIENDS
Stay organized and in control with 24/7 access to all of your important events, projects and files --whether you're at work, at home or on the road.

You can share your calendar, projects and files so everyone in your office is up to date. Plus, search your entire group to find times when everyone is available to meet, manage company resources and much more.

Organize your entire team for as low as $9.95 per year (and yes, that's where the decimal place is supposed to be!)

Tap here to get started right away.

-- Advertisement --

How To Save Jobs
This book is about how to create and save jobs. Believe it or not, there's not a single book out there that specifically focuses on job creation and preservation -- until now.

This book, by ZATZ editor-in-chief David Gewirtz, is about helping your business work better. It's about helping you change the things you need to change so your company can perform more effectively.

Plus, through a grant from ZATZ, it's a free download.

Read it and reap.

ZATZ Home  ·  News  ·  Back Issues  ·  Credits/Trademarks ·  Link To Us
Copyright © 2003-2012, ZATZ Publishing. All rights reserved worldwide.
Hosted by Prominic.NET
Editor's Login